top of page
sublationglyph_edited.png
1 hour ago
17 min read


An Ergodic Left

November 16, 2026


I was recently having a conversation with a couple Marxists about Politics (whatever that means), Pessimism, and where we fit in relation to The Grand Narrative of History. It occurred to me, in that conversation, to boldly state that "I am some kind of Leftist," even if I don't know what that means.


The world we live in seems to be a psychotic one, blood, shit, and semen constantly flying through the air and spattering against every available surface as we all slowly suffocate and perish under the weight of our material conditions. That's a bit extreme, but it's how I feel; and I don't think things like sitting around in coffee shops and discussing Karl Marx as a kind of Catechism of Liberation is quite up to the task of setting things right in this mad Pollockian future.


What do I think it means to be "some kind of Leftist," why do I think it matters, and why am I writing about it right now? I aim to answer those questions, dear reader, so bear with me and buckle up!


Many people have lofted diagnoses at the world we live in. I just did it here, when I was talking about Psychosis, and I’m about to do it again. People have tied the woes of the world to Narcissism or Algorithms and Platforms; people have come up with terms like Neo- or Techno-Feudalism; people have opined that Data and Surveillance have become the new Productive Base of society; people have claimed that Postmodernism is the problem, and all we need to do is return to a grand unifying narrative; and many more claims have been made in attempts to reckon with today's world and get the motor of History moving again …


I aim to argue that the world we live in today is both a Paranoiac world and a Perverse world, and, that it is so fragmented that it makes very little sense to talk about it as ‘One World’ in the first place. I then aim to discuss The Left as a current of Radical Hope for Emancipation, as a position set against the Operationalizing, Positivism, Functionalism, Productivism, and Identification inherent in Modernity—as Modernity, proper, provided an opportunity to cast off all Grand Narratives and create new ones, but we failed to avail ourselves of this opportunity and have fallen into a Postmodern condition that runs Perverse and Paranoid simulations of Premodern Grand Narratives to keep us all locked into some Identity or other as a way to burn off the surplus energy set free by Modernity.


I will be drawing on multiple frameworks here; Lacan, Marx, Baudrillard, my own concepts of The Ergodic Ethic (inspired heavily by Levinas, Bataille, and Zizek), as well as the concept of Retrostition/Hypostition to discuss the Perverse and the Paranoid characteristics of Modernity. I will heavily employ Lacan's concept of The Superego and set it alongside both Perversion and Paranoia in place of the Big Other, as one feature of Modernity is that the Lack in the Big Other was exposed, and as a consequence the Grand Narratives had to pivot to the Superego as the source of Law and Legitimation. [1] In this conceptualization the Big Other functions precisely because it is Lacking, it allows the Subject to participate in the creation of the social order, by way of Inherent Transgression primarily; and with this relationship broken, the Superego takes up the position of a concrete source of symbolic interpellation that is not Lacking and thus strips the Subject of their social being and replaces it with a hard code—hence the Perversion or the Paranoia.


I aim to discuss all of this and then, once again, situate The Left within it as a current of Radical Hope running through history, that never gives up on the idea of Emancipation, rather than an Identity or a Category or a collection of qualifiers in reference to a Particularist struggle.


We’ll start by discussing the various diagnoses of society because none of them are wrong, exactly, and that’s the problem.


Christopher Lasch was writing about a Culture of Narcissism before I was born, and he wasn’t crazy; a society which liquidates every stable external structure of meaning is bound to produce subjects who fall back on the only structure left standing—the Self. Shoshana Zuboff isn’t crazy either when she points to Surveillance as a new productive base in its own right, how our behaviors are now catalogued, extracted, refined, and sold back to us as prediction. Techno-Feudalism – whether you prefer Yanis Varoufakis, McKenzie Wark, Michel Luc Bellemare, Yuval Harari, or someone else – isn’t wrong to notice that rent seems to have superseded surplus labor in some regards as a locus of value for Capital, meaning a handful of platforms now function less like competitors in a market and more like the landlords of the market itself. And the people clamoring over each other, and themselves, to champion a return to some Grand Unifying Narrative aren’t simply reactionary nostalgics; they’re correct in noticing a Lack—they’re just wrong about what to do about it. Each of these accounts points to a real symptom. What none of them do is tell us what disease can cause symptoms this varied and contradictory, symptoms that show up simultaneously as total certainty and utter meaninglessness, ubiquitous surveillance and complete chaos.


So. The world we live in today is Paranoiac, and it is also Perverse. And, it is not, strictly, a single world at all.


We’ll start with the fragmentation, as that’s the least controversial claim I’ll be making, and it sets up the rest. The idea that we live in a single, coherent “world” which everyone more or less shares, disagreeing only about how to interpret it, was already a mistake by the mid-twentieth century, and is a flat out fairy tale today. We have, instead of a single world, a series of overlapping, mutually unintelligible information ecologies; each internally consistent and furnished with its own set of facts, heroes, villains, and eschatologies—none answerable to a shared arbiter, because the shared arbiter is precisely what’s missing from the picture. We aren’t up against “polarization,” as that implies two poles on a single axis, a single map we’re arguing over which way to label North and which South. The world we live in today resembles what happened at Babel, if you’ll indulge me; a single language shattering into incongruent dialects faster than anyone can recuperate it with a dictionary. People can, and do, watch the same footage and walk away having witnessed entirely different events, both rationally supported by the ecology the viewers inhabit. From nowhere ther eis no view left to appeal to, because the view-from-nowhere-that-never-was is precisely the thing that Modernity dissolved, and something far more dangerous took its place.


There’s the fragmentation. Now for the Paranoia and the Perversion, which are two different responses people mount to this condition, and which is why the various diagnoses keep talking past each other—they see one or the other of these responses, and they mistake it for the whole enchilada.


The perverse response shores up The Enemy. The pervert, in the clinical sense, isn’t the one who breaks the rules, but rather the one who positions themself as the necessary instrument which keeps the rules running—servicing the Other’s Lack rather than suffering it. You’ll see this everywhere once you start looking for it. The professional culture warrior whose entire livelihood depends on the enemy remaining monstrous. The activist who experiences the weakening of their opposition not as victory but as a kind of vertigo, because the opposition was never really an obstacle to their identity but rather the condition for it. I’ve written about this as Hypostition [2]—the structure by which a subject or a movement unconsciously works to keep their enemy alive and thriving, because a defeated enemy would mean facing the fact that there was never a settled Self underneath the fight, there was only ever the fight.

The Perverse world is the present stretched to infinity; a permanent, low-grade war of position in which everyone is always losing and winning is never allowed, as that would end the only thing holding anyone’s identity together.


The Paranoid response operates by way of the past rather than an eternal present. Where the Pervert maintains an enemy, the Paranoiac manufactures a cause. Something has clearly gone wrong, something is clearly missing; and rather than sitting with the possibility that things are simply broken and contingent and nobody in particular is responsible, the Paranoiac reconstructs a coherent hidden agency who is responsible and has been in control the whole time. I called this Retrostition and went into more detail elsewhere—the conversion of ordinary unhappiness, plain disappointment, into secret knowledge—the red thread hypotheses, the concealed cabal of elite, the Algorithm as God; all of it manufactured ex post facto to explain why reality, and more importantly Modernity, has failed to deliver on its promise. What’s important here is that the Paranoiac’s cynicism is really a form of faith. Believing in the hidden mastermind is, structurally, believing that someone, somewhere, still has their hands on the steering wheel. That belief is more palatable than the alternative, which is that nobody, in fact, does. 


Put all this together and what do you get? Bibbidy-bobbidy-boo—it’s at least a more robust diagnosis than Narcissism or Surveillance or Feudalism alone can give you, it at least gives a structural account of why the world looks like a set of permanent tribal wars and overlapping conspiracies—those are the two available shapes that belief takes when the thing that used to hold belief together comes apart. Which brings us to what that thing was, and why it came apart.


Modernity’s real achievement, underneath all the powerlooms and engines and space programs and computers and mechanical Turks, was exposing the fact that the Big Other does not exist. The Big Other is the field of language, law, and shared convention that a subject appeals to when they want to know what something means, what the rules actually are, whether they’re “doing it right.” For most of human history that field was guaranteed, or seemed to be at any rate, by something absolute — God, The King, The Natural Order, The Cosmos as a meaningfully arranged whole. Crucially, the Big Other worked because everyone secretly knew, without ever quite admitting it, that it was incomplete, that there was some untouchable surplus that simply escaped intelligibility. Nobody has ever truly known what God wants, that’s kinda his whole gimmick; nobody has ever known precisely what the law demands in a particular case, hence deliberation and interpretation; nobody but The King knows how his justice applies to your specific grievance. That Lack, the gap, is precisely how and why society works in the first place, it’s what allows a subject to participate in social being and the production of meaning rather than just being a receiver. The marquee form of participation in the collective load-bearing of a society is inherent transgression—the unwritten exception, the knowing wink, eccentric interpretations, the thing that everyone does which isn’t expressly in the rulebook but that the rulebook secretly relies on to keep functioning at all. We don’t merely obey the Big Other, we co-author it, by way of the gap left open for you.


Modernity pulled the curtain back and showed that there never was a man behind it. Disenchantment, the Death of God, the discovery that the cosmos is indifferent physics rather than a meaningfully arranged order, the demonstration that the kings and priests and traditions had been making it up all along just like everyone else, the replacement of the untouchable surplus with the ultimate justification — Utility and Exchange — all of this amounted to a genuinely radical discovery, that the Big Other wasn’t whole and never had been, wasn’t backed by anything absolute, was ‘lacking’ the whole time. This should have been an opening. If nobody was ever really in charge of meaning, then meaning was always open to being authored, collectively, by those who lived inside of it. Modernity handed us the tools and the historical moment to begin writing our own Grand Narratives with our eyes wide open, knowing full-well that they were our own constructions and to organize a form of freedom around that knowledge rather than settle for the stultifying, if comforting, lie that it’s all out of our hands.


We tried. The Enlightenment tried. Marxism, at its most serious, tried. Marxism is best understood not as the search for a replacement god, but, as I’ve argued elsewhere, as one continuous Humanist wager that a species which produces itself through free, conscious activity can eventually reconcile itself with nature and its own labor rather than being estranged from both.


This is where I get off the Marxism train, but only because it’s arrived at its station while my destination lies further down the track. Reconciliation isn’t the Good that it initially sounds like. Reconciliation is an end state, a moment when contradiction finally settles down and stops asking anything more of you. A subject who arrives at reconciliation will stop being a subject in any sense worth fighting for. The Human Subject is barred, split down the middle by its entry into language, and that split was never a temporary embarrassment on the way to some future wholeness. If you close the gap, you don’t get a liberated person, you get an Object, something settled and finished and done, a cutesy bauble sitting on God’s perfect bookshelf. Emancipation isn’t something that happens to you, a settlement that arrives one day and holds. Freedom isn’t something you are, a state you reach and quietly occupy, like a job title. These are things you must do. They’re Acts, verbs as opposed to nouns. They’re never-ending contradictions, they demand just as much from you as they ever provide, forever. No discount for preferred members and no final receipt provided for accounting at the end. Being a Human Subject is an open demand, and it’s the only place any of us can ever be free; so fighting to close the gap and shore up the lack presupposes that we are finished things, God’s little Objects.


None of this means that the attempt wasn’t worth making or that the struggle is somehow beneath us; if anything it’s the opposite, since the struggle you decide to stay engaged in is worth infinitely more than a reconciliation you can only ever hope for. But somewhere along the way we lost our nerve for the struggle itself, which is a different species of failure than that of simply falling short of a reconciliation that was never going to arrive anyway. The new narratives curdled into their own forms of domination, stalled out, or got absorbed and metabolized by the very market logic they set out in opposition to. And rather than sitting in the discomfort of a genuinely open field of meaning, rather than tolerating the vertigo of Lack long enough to write something new into it, we backslid. Rather than the liberation promised by Modernity, we got the Postmodern condition instead; and that condition is not, contrary to the popular complaint, the absence of Grand Narratives, but rather an oversupply of counterfeit ones.


What circulates today are simulations of premodern total narratives; nationalisms without nations behind them, religious cosmologies repackaged as lifestyle branding, tribes you can join simply by liking the right posts, conspiracies that situate you squarely in a secret drama of Good and Evil the way that scripture used to. Today’s narratives aren’t copies of an original that still exists somewhere out there; they’re simulacra, signs that generate the semblance of a total, meaningful order with no actual referent. They provide what the old Grand Narratives used to—a place in History, Truth, clear enemies, total explanation—without any of the metaphysical baggage that used to make those things costly, binding, or true. They’re hyperreal grand narratives, exactly the shape that the Paranoid and the Perverse responses take to the Modern moment, permanent tribal enemies and hidden masterminds to uncover, over and over, ad infinitum.


Why do these counterfeits keep winning out over the harder, more honest work of actually building something new? Every system that produces more energy than it strictly needs to survive must do something with that surplus, must spend it somehow; the only choice is between spending it gloriously in a sovereign manner, or having it forced catastrophically from you. Premodern societies had elaborate mechanisms to deal with this surplus; festivals, sacrifice, cathedral-building, the whole ritual architecture of the sacred was largely a technology for burning off surplus without burning down the social order in the process. Modernity, in exposing the Big Other and discrediting those old channels, released an enormous amount of surplus energy and never built an adequate mechanism for handling it. The genuinely Emancipatory project—that of writing a new narrative together, with no guarantees and no preordained endings—would’ve been one way to spend it. We didn’t really do that. Instead, the surplus gets burned off in the low, ugly, endlessly renewable fires of Identity conflict—outrage, culture war—the permanent skirmish that consumes enormous amounts of energy and produces nothing.


This is where the appeals to the Big Other and the Superego start to make sense. The pivot from the Big Other as the incomplete, or groundless, ground of society to the Superego as the complete and total guarantor explains why the counterfeit narratives take on their specific Paranoid or Perverse character. Once the Lack in the Big Other is exposed and can’t be papered back over, the position it used to occupy doesn’t just sit empty. Something rushes in to fill the empty space, and what rushes in, structurally, is the Superego. The Superego isn’t just the Big Other with a new paint job; it’s precisely what the Big Other isn’t — total, uninterpretable, never satisfied. Where the old law left you a gap to actively interpret it, to transgress it a little, to participate in it; the Superego only ever issues one command — to endlessly enjoy, do more, be more, never be incomplete, and it never tells you when you’ve done enough, because doing enough would require some sort of Lack in the first place, and the Superego knows no Lack. It’s a never-ending positive feedback loop. It functions less like a rulebook you can interpret and negotiate with and more like a hard code you’ve got no choice but to run, whether you consent to it or not.


Facing a code like that, the subject has only a couple of moves available, and they map directly onto the Paranoid and Perverse responses described above. One move is to become the instrument of the code, to disavow your own gap and identify with the machine itself, servicing it, embodying it, enjoying your own total submission to the co-dependent content-producing always-online version of yourself that the platform Superego demands. That’s the perverse move, the Hypostitional move, the present stretched into an infinite, exhausting performance of duty. The other move is to insist that behind the code there must be someone, some concrete, coherent, all-knowing agent who wrote it and is running it on purpose; a malicious author is at least someone you can name, locate, and someday defeat—which is far more bearable a thought than a code that has no author at all and simply runs itself. That’s the paranoid move, the Retrostitional move, the fantasy of invisible hands tipping scales rather than the reality of accidents and contingency. Both these moves are ways of refusing the one fact that’s actually on the table, which is that nobody, not God or The King or The Algorithm or a shadowy cabal is fully in control. The guarantee was never given. Nobody was ever going to write the new Narrative for us, that was always our responsibility.


There is, however, another move to make, and it’s one neither the Paranoid nor the Perverse subject can make. It involves what I’ve been calling, for lack of a better name, an Ergodic Ethic, and it is the move that The Left, at its best, is built out of.


Ergodic comes from ergon, the Greek word for work, deed, or action. It doesn’t invoke labor in the sense of drudgery and not productivity in reference to exchange, just the plain fact of doing something, of a deed being enacted in the world. Ethics, from an Ergodic perspective, is built on three primary pillars.


The first is that ethics precedes identity, not the other way around. Society places a demand on you which you did not choose, cannot discharge, and cannot use to build a stable sense of who you are. You are, essentially, society’s hostage; held responsible before you’ve had the chance to decide whether you like it or not; which rules out, right at the start, that an Ethical deed can serve accumulation, good works banked toward the purchase of a virtuous identity. Ethics isn’t for you, and the account never closes.


The Second is that a genuinely free act must cost something. It has to be an expenditure rather than an investment. The problem with this Epoch of Superego is that it turns everything into a restricted economy where the only option is catastrophic accumulation. Real freedom shows up in the glorious, useless, non-recoupable gesture, the thing done for the sake of the doing rather than the expected return. This keeps the Ethical deed from collapsing back into productivism. It cannot be optimized. There is no measurable return.


The last is that everything is contingent. The Ethical act doesn’t wait around for a permission slip, the Ethical actor knows that one is never coming. The Ethical act doesn’t discover its own justification in advance. It completes its work and afterward finds, or creates, the ground it's standing on. This is the obverse of the Paranoid, Retrostitional, act; not a cousin. Retrostition manufactures a hidden cause to justify the failure to act, converting impotence to hidden knowledge. The Ethical act does the opposite; it is done without a guarantee, and only when it is carried out does it install new coordinates into a world that didn’t have them beforehand.


Put together, the Ergodic, or Ethical, deed is an unauthorized, ungrounded, non-accumulating act performed in response to a demand that exceeds you, that comes at a real cost, and that doesn’t wait for a complete identity or a hidden cause or an all-powerful master to certify it. It becomes immediately clear that this is designed to resist the things I flagged earlier in this essay as characteristic of Modernity’s failures. It can’t be operationalized, because it isn’t a reliably repeatable procedure, but a response to a singular demand, made new each time. It isn’t positivistic because it doesn’t rely on verifiable, countable facts. It resists Functionalism because it isn’t performed for the sake of what it accomplishes within a system, but for the sake of the person in front of you. It refuses Productivism because it’s an act of expenditure rather than of production. And it can’t be frozen into an Identity, a fixed label you can wear for the rest of time in lieu of continuing to the work, because it doesn’t accumulate into anything, it has to be redone, over and over again.


That last point is, I think, the whole answer to the question that I opened with.


Being “some kind of Leftist” is not a matter of holding the correct positions, subscribing to the correct Identity, or fighting on behalf of one particularist struggle against rival particularist struggle for a pool of restricted attention—which is exactly what culture war logic does to every struggle, and is both paranoid and perverse; it relies on an eternal enemy and a total explanation for why things never get better. The Left, in the sense that I actually care about, is something older and less comforting than all that. It’s a current, running underneath and sometimes against the official history of the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, a current of Radical Hope for Emancipation. The key word is Radical, thoroughly committed to something extreme, even when there seems to be no good reason for it; committed to the idea that people can in fact someday be free, together, even after every Grand Narrative that once promised such freedom has failed, stagnated, or been co-opted. It’s a fidelity to the wager itself, rather than to any particular scoring metric, which is precisely why emancipation is better understood as a new way of relating to the present than as some future state you’re waiting to arrive at. You don’t get to bank it, you don’t get to finish it, you do it again tomorrow.



This is an Ergodic, or Ethical, Left—it’s not a club you can join, not a set of qualifiers you can accumulate, or an Identity you can relax inside of; it’s an ongoing, unauthorized, non-guaranteed practice of acting on behalf of the emancipation of people you will never fully know. There’s no comfort of a permanent enemy and no assurance of a hidden enemy to explain impotence and failure. It’s a lot harder than picking a side in a war everyone else is already fighting, and far harder indeed than deciding the whole thing is hopeless and retreating to passively watch the blood, shit, and semen fly. But, it’s the one response to our mad Pollockian world which doesn’t ask that same mad world for guarantee or approval or assurance before it acts. You act, where you already are, for and with the person already in front of you, and you let the narratives and justifications catch up later, if they ever even do. There’s no reconciliation waiting at the end of any rainbows, the contradictions don’t close. That, as best as I can tell, is what it means to be “some kind of Leftist.” It’s not an answer that History owes you, or even one that it can provide. It’s not a peace either. It’s a demand that you owe History right now, and again tomorrow, and the day after that, and for as long as you insist on being a Human Subject rather than a completed process, an Object on God’s bookshelf.







 
 
An Ergodic Left
An Ergodic Left
Bryce Nance
The People Are Not One
The People Are Not One
Ralph Leonard
Liberal Socialism: A Response to Critics
Liberal Socialism: A Response to Critics
Matt McManus
EC_cover_5x8.jpg
Was Lenin PMC? How Elite Theory doesn’t fit the movement for socialism
Chris Cutrone
White Fields II
M. Rowton
A Critique of Ralph Leonard: Either You Love America or You Love Its Power
Fakhry Al-Serdawi
White Fields
M. Rowton
bottom of page